Crib Mattress Reviews
Jake Comfort | Updated: November 2022
Jake Comfort | Updated: June 2022
We have an affiliate relationship with and receive compensation from companies whose products we review on this site. We are independently owned and the opinions expressed here are our own.
Everyone knows that babies are a joy. That means you want to make sure your baby is as safe and comfortable as possible. Moreover, a comfortable baby is less likely to wake up at night, and more likely to sleep through the night.
That means you are going to want to be sure to get the best crib mattress possible. We have put together this helpful page of crib mattress reviews to aid you in your search for the best option. There is also a brief guide that will help you determine which mattress is best for your needs.
We will look at mattresses from some of the most popular retailers, as well as a couple of options that come from specialized vendors. Use the information in this review to decide which crib mattress is the best option for your little bundle of joy.
Things to Look for in a Crib Mattress
There are several important factors you should consider before you purchase a crib mattress. Making sure you know what you are looking for ahead of time will prevent a lot of hassle and headaches later. It also means that you can research each of your options carefully to ensure that the mattress provides the level of safety and comfort that your baby deserves.
The first thing to consider is the size of the mattress. Make sure you measure the inside space of your crib. You want to make sure the mattress will fit inside the crib without bunching up or leaving large gaps. Also, when it comes to the size of the mattress, you should make sure the bedding should not be thicker than 6 inches. This helps ensure that the baby will not be able to find their way over the rail of the crib and works to protect them in other ways.
Materials are the second consideration you should keep in mind when you are shopping for a crib mattress. There are lots of different reasons why making sure you get the right materials are important. First, you should make sure that the material will work to support your child’s spine. This can help prevent injuries and aid in healthy development. The second thing to consider with materials is allergies. Some parents prefer hypo-allergenic materials for a crib mattress because there is no way to know what, if any, allergies your child will have. That means hypo-allergenic materials may be the safer way to go.
The materials also matter because you want to make sure they are waterproof and stain-resistant. While babies are magical, they can also get messy. Waterproof materials will help ensure that your baby has a dry place to sleep. It also prevents smells from accumulating and sticking around and keeps things healthy and clean. Furthermore, it is also imperative that you look for a mattress that has washable materials, especially the cover (provided the cover prevents liquids from seeping into the core). Babies are messy and unpredictable – the last thing you want is to have to replace a mattress every time an accident happens. Many mattresses have washable materials, so be sure to consider that when you are on the hunt for a new crib mattress.
Construction type is another factor in choosing the best crib mattress. Depending on your situation and needs, you can get foam, innerspring, or organic crib mattresses. Each of these has its advantages and drawbacks, so you should carefully consider your needs before choosing candidates for your purchase.
Finally, you will want to factor in the cost. Most prices on crib mattresses run between $50 and $400. Organic crib mattresses tend to be in the $80 to $400 price range. You should use the price, along with the other factors listed here, to help narrow down which crib mattress is the best choice for you.
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review
Naturepedic understands the importance of baby-safe products, and that is why the brand uses certified organic and non-toxic materials that are tested for chemical emissions by Greenguard. The company is also an advocate for the environment, holding prestigious rewards such as the Practice Green Health Champion for Change and Ernst & Young Regional Entrepreneur of the Year. In addition to baby products, Naturepedic makes organic and eco-friendly mattresses for kids and adults. Naturepedic offers three different mattress types – Classic, Breathable, and Breathable Ultra. These mattresses are available in mini crib, standard crib, and oval crib shapes. We are going to take a detailed look at the Classic and Breathable mattress.
Classic Organic Mattress
Starting at $259, the Classic mattress has five essential features – a wipe-clean waterproof surface, firmness support layer, organic cotton batting, 150-coil innerspring, and a wavesupport™ core. Naturepedic crafted the mattress with firm support to conform to guidelines set forth by pediatricians and the CPSC. There are also reinforced edges that make this mattress suitable for toddlers.
Unlike other crib mattresses that use synthetic foams and fabrics, this mattress has pure forms of organic cotton grown in the United States. To complement the cotton, there is a waterproof coating made from non-GMO sugarcane. And although this mattress has several features, it does not weigh the mattress down. The patented Wavesupport core is durable but still lightweight, so it is easy to move the mattress and change the bedding.
Breathable Organic Mattress
Slightly more expensive at $349, the breathable mattress has a few key features that set it apart from the Classic mattress. To begin, the organic cotton fabric used to construct the mattress has three-dimensional breathable space. There is also a 252-coil innerspring compared to the 150-coil innerspring in the classic model. With a firmer side for infants and a medium-firm side for toddlers, your child will not outgrow this mattress as fast.
The three-dimensional breathable space acts as a critical safety component for your little one. This feature allows heat underneath the baby to dissipate more efficiently and helps to regulate the baby’s temperature throughout the night. The baby can breathe through the fabric thanks to the three-dimensional material. According to studies, the increase in breathability improves safety because it enhances airflow. If the cover ever gets dirty, no problem – the breathable function rests below another washable cover that protects the mattress. And like all Naturepedic’s crib mattresses, the Breathable mattress is Made-Safe and Greenguard certified.
Newton Baby Crib Mattress Review
The Newton Baby brand revolves around four core values: community, quality, innovation, and transparency. Newton’s team of experts spent years researching the perfect solution to improve the quality of sleep. After the team’s years of hard work, it concluded that the “healthy development of your baby” depends on “good quality sleep.” The founder of Newton Baby, Michael Rothbard, knows what it is like to have kids with sleep issues. After facing the typical struggles of parenthood, Michael launched Newton Baby to create a product superior to the conventional crib mattress.
Original Crib Mattress
Inarguably Newton’s best-selling mattress, the Original model is 100% breathable and 100% washable. For $299.99, the Original mattress falls right between the Essential and Waterproof model. The mattress is available in four colors – white, gray, beige, and blue. According to CPSC lab testing, a baby gets 97% more air breathing through a Newton crib mattress compared to a conventional mattress. With several awards, including Mom’s Choice and Family Choice, safety is one of Newton’s top priorities.
The original mattress is a 2-stage mattress – both infants and toddlers can use it. Inside the mattress, you will find a Wovenaire core, made of 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer. Moreover, the mattress boasts a washable cover with a convenient zip. While this mattress is not organic, it has Greenguard certification and meets Australian’s firmness standards.
Waterproof Crib Mattress
Newton Baby’s most premium mattress is the Waterproof crib mattress. It is available in two colors, white and gray, and costs $349.99. This mattress is like the Original mattress – it is a two-stage mattress meaning one side is for infants and the other size is for toddlers. The main difference is the fact that this mattress has a waterproof TPU barrier that covers the toddler’s side. Like the Original mattress, it boasts a 3-D space cover and has a core made of 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer.
The Waterproof crib mattress, along with the three other crib mattresses, comes with a 100-night free trial. Newton Baby ships its mattresses via FedEx, and you can expect to receive them within 3 to 8 business days. Thanks to Newton’s carefully crafted design, you can wash both the cover and the core of the mattress. Most crib mattresses only come with a washable cover – you cannot typically wash the entire mattress. The mattresses do not have latex, springs, or glue, ultimately resulting in an enhanced sleeping experience and a happier baby.
Modern Nursery is not just a mattress store – it sells nursery furniture, toys, baby gear, and even car seats. If you are looking for a mattress, you will be pleased to know that Modern Nursery has over fifty mattresses available for purchase. The Modern Nursery does not manufacture its mattresses, but rather sells award-winning and safe mattresses from a variety of different brands. As an online e-commerce store, Modern Nursery focuses on four key elements that define its success: comfort, happiness, style, and responsibility. With frequent promotions and discounts, the Modern Nursery is a one-stop-shop for all your nursery needs.
Supreme All Foam with Oxyflow Visco Full Mattress
This is not your typical crib mattress. The Supreme All Foam mattress is part of the premium Starlight product line and reaches 6” in height. There are two sides to the mattress – one for infants and one for toddlers. The infant side is extra-firm and made of plant oils and visco foam (also known as memory foam). With the Oxyflow design, the other side of the mattress conforms better to a toddler’s body. As a safety feature, the mattress features a woven fire barrier and BabySealed seams.
Everyone knows how messy a crib mattress can get, and that is why this mattress has a stain-resistant and odor-resistant deluxe knit fabric. The cover is custom-fitted to each mattress and you can take it off and wash it. This medical-grade mattress has a woven ribbon design to seal its appearance and a sewn seam. And to take another step to ensure safety the mattress features a BreatheWell core that helps boost the mattress’s airflow.
Pure Core Non-Toxic Crib Mattress + Hybrid Cover
At just around $200, the Pure Core Non-Toxic crib mattress + hybrid cover is a budget-friendly option. The mattress comes with a 10-year warranty and the cover comes with a 1-year warranty. Like the Supreme All Foam mattress, this mattress dual-sided with one side for infants and one side for a toddler. A quilted hybrid mattress hugs the mattress, protecting the mattress with a waterproof backing. The hybrid cover is easily removable and washable.
This mattress is made in Taiwan with safety in mind – it contains no chemical flame retardants and features a square corner design. Unlike competing crib mattresses, this non-toxic mattress contains no polyurethane foam, vinyl, or PVC. It is also hypoallergenic and is resistant to all allergens and dust mites. This mattress has a polyester/cotton outer layer and polyester inside. If you want an affordable and extremely safe mattress, the Pure Cure Non-Toxic mattress should be at the top of your list.
Avocado Green Mattress
Based out of Los Angeles, Avocado is a certified B corporation – one that is legally required to consider the impact of its decisions on all stakeholders, including its workers and the environment. The company has a mission to offer the most sustainable brands in the world with 100% organic and non-toxic materials. This innovative company offers a huge variety of products, including bed frames, bedding, and mattresses, of course. You will find mattresses for both children and adults. Avocado offers two crib mattresses – an Organic crib mattress and a Luxury Organic crib mattress.
Organic Crib Mattress
At $279, the Organic crib mattress is a bargain for a non-toxic and eco-friendly mattress. The mattress is made of only wholesome ingredients – 100% GOLS organic latex and 100% GOTS organic wool along with organic cotton. Avocado sources its materials from farms in India that use sustainable harvesting practices (no pesticides, herbicides, or fertilizers). Certain materials, such as Avocado’s organic certified latex and wool come from its farms, eliminating the need for a middleman.
The mattress itself is dual-sided, with one side for infants and the other side for toddlers. The infant side boasts a firm quilted pattern on top of the base support made of coconut husk fiber. For those between the ages of one and four, the opposite side of the mattress has a plusher firmness level and features an extra layer of GOTS organic certified cotton for additional breathability. And no need to worry if this mattress is not the right fit for your little one – it comes with a 30-night trial period and a 25-year limited warranty.
Luxury Organic Crib Mattress
Priced at over $1,000, the Luxury Organic crib mattress is not a budget-friendly mattress. Avocado handmakes this mattress in Los Angeles with premium organic materials and 170 ultra-premium cotton-wrapped coils. This mattress features standard cribs and boasts a two-stage design, meaning it can accommodate both toddlers and infants. Each mattress is made to order, so expect the delivery time to take longer than a standard mattress.
Following Avocado’s mission to maintain an eco-friendly and sustainable brand, the Luxury Organic mattress does not have any harmful materials such as chemical adhesives, polyurethane, polyethylene, or flame retardants. Furthermore, it holds Greengold certification and does not emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs). The infant side of the mattress boasts a quilt with 100% GOTS organic cotton knit. Right underneath the quilt is base support made of coconut husk fiber. On the other side of the mattress, the toddler side, you will find a support layer of GOLS organic certified latex, cotton-wrapped foils, and reinforced coco-fibers to enhance the perimeter’s edge.
Ikea Crib Mattress Reviews
Ikea always has a decent number of options when it comes to crib mattresses. These range in price, style and features. We’ll look at some of the most popular crib mattresses from Ikea so you can see what they have on offer and decide if Ikea is an option you should explore further. Keep in mind that prices may change based on your location and the time of year you’re making your purchase.
Ikea DRÖMMANDE Pocket spring mattress for crib
This mattress is a great example of a quality innerspring crib mattress. It’s made with a pocketed spring core and is lined with a unique blend of coconut fiber and natural latex.
The use of natural fibers for the lining will appeal to parents who are concerned about exposing their babies to chemicals. Moreover, the mattress is extremely resilient, which means it can be used for any potential future siblings.
One of the best features of the DRÖMMANDE is that you can remove the cover. It’s machine washable, so you can get out any stains or messes that happen in bed. The fact that it’s machine washable in warm water also means that you can feel confident that you’re eliminating any extra germs that might be sticking around.
Another nice aspect of the DRÖMMANDE is the that the pocketed spring system allows for more airflow than you’d get in a foam mattress. That means your baby will get a more consistent and even sleeping temperature. This might help them stay comfortable and sleeping for longer.
Finally, the mattress has a durable and safe side handle. This is a nice additional touch that makes it easy to carry the mattress, remove the cover when you want to wash it, and flip it when you’re making the bed.
The DRÖMMANDE can be purchased for $150 at Ikea.
Ikea JÄTTETRÖTT Pocket spring mattress for crib
The JÄTTETRÖTT is made from sustainable materials. Its construction is free from harmful chemicals and it meets all required safety regulations for cri mattresses.
The outer cover for this mattress is removable and can be machine washed on hot. That means you can be confident your baby’s mattress will be healthy and clean. It also helps you maintain the fresh look of a white crib mattress without having to worry about the various stains and messes that can happen to any baby.
The pocketed spring design means that this mattress does a good job of letting air move freely. This helps to maintain a steady temperature for your baby while also working to reduce any smells that might linger in the mattress.
An additional safety feature you get with the JÄTTETRÖTT Is that it has a fixed inner cover. This means that, even if the mattress gets a tear, your child will not be able to reach the inner contents of the mattress, preventing them from putting it in their mouth.
The mattress, like all Ikea mattresses, is sized to fit perfectly within Ikea cribs. That makes it an appealing option if you’ve found the crib you want but don’t want to worry about getting a mattress that fits.
The JÄTTETRÖTT can be purchased at Ikea stores or online for $100
Ikea KRUMMELUR Foam mattress for crib
The last Ikea crib mattress we’ll look at is the KRUMMELUR. Unlike the other two Ikea mattresses we discussed, this is a foam mattress. It serves as a good example of a foam crib mattress that covers all of the important things you should be looking for in a crib mattress.
First, the foam in this mattress is made from sustainable and safe materials. There aren’t any harmful chemicals used during manufacturing. Furthermore, the manufacturer abides by incredibly strict safety regulations to ensure that this crib mattress will be safe for baby.
One of the biggest problems with foam crib mattresses is that they can be a bit of a hassle to clean. The KRUMMELUR makes this easy with its inner cover. This cover allows the mattress to hold its shape while you clean the other cover. The inner cover also provides an extra degree of fire safety while prevent children from putting the mattress contents in their mouths.
Speaking of which, cleaning the outer cover is a breeze, as the cover is machine washable on hot. This helps keep the cover looking great while making sure it’s safe and healthy for your child.
Finally, this mattress has a different surface on each side. One side is wavy and has a medium-firm feel, while the other side is smoother and firmer. That means you can find out what kind of sleeping environment your baby likes best to help them (and you!) sleep through the night.
How to Save Money on a Crib Mattress
While the average crib mattress only costs a couple of hundred dollars, it never hurts to save extra money when you get the chance. There are three ways to save money on a crib mattress: look for promotions and discounts, buy a dual-sided mattress, and spend a little more on a durable mattress.
Look for Promotions and Discounts
Many of the companies that we will review below offer a variety of special discounts and promotions. Be sure to take advantage of anything that can help save you money on your next crib mattress. Some retailers mark down their infant products during certain times of the year, such as February and September.
Buy a Dual-Sided Mattress
As you read our crib mattress reviews, you will notice that most of them are dual-sided. If you get a dual-sided mattress, you do not need to buy a new mattress when your infant eventually reaches toddler age. The infant side of the mattress is typically plush, whereas the toddler side is firmer. You may also see a dual-sided mattress that is not for a different age. For example, an infant mattress might have two sides that are mirror images of each other, ultimately resulting in increased longevity.
Spend a Little More on a Durable Mattress
While this might sound a little counterintuitive, you should spend more on a durable mattress instead of buying a cheap one. You should look for mattresses made of 100% organic cotton, reinforced edges, and a high spring count if it is an innerspring mattress. Spending more may also result in a longer trial period or warranty. Spending a little more now will help you save in the long run.
What Safety Certifications Should the Mattress Have?
It is imperative to make sure you buy a safe mattress for your little one. There are several certifications that you should look for if you are searching for a new crib mattress: Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS), and Greenguard Gold. Holding Greenguard Gold certification is almost a must. Products that earn this certification undergo testing processes the measure the amount of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that the mattress gives off. Buying a Greenguard Gold mattress ensures that it is non-toxic and will not cause harm to your child.