Select Page
We have an affiliate relationship with and receive compensation from companies whose products we review on this site. We are independently owned and the opinions expressed here are our own.
We have an affiliate relationship with and receive compensation from companies whose products we review on this site. We are independently owned and the opinions expressed here are our own.

Best Mattress Toppers

Jake Comfort  |  Updated: January 2, 2020

Best Mattress Toppers

Sometimes there’s a fine line between a good bed and a great bed. A mattress topper can push you over that line. We’ve assembled a list of 5 of the best mattress toppers on the market today. We’ll cover each one in detail, but first we’ll go over the reasons to get a mattress topper and the things you should look for when picking out the best mattress topper for you.

Reasons to Get a Mattress Topper

There are lots of reasons to get a mattress topper. However, the main reasons are to adjust how your bed feels. You can get a topper that makes your bed feel firmer or softer. You can also get a topper to add a layer of comfortable material and get a bit of extra life out of your current bed without purchasing a whole new mattress. As a result, toppers are a great way to enhance your sleep without breaking the bank!

Picking the Best Mattress Topper

Now that you understand why you should consider a mattress topper you need to know what goes into making the best mattress topper. This guide will give you all the information you need to make an informed decision regarding which topper is right for you.

Materials

One of the first things you should consider are the materials. Many toppers are made with foam, but there are lots of different kinds of foam on the market. Moreover, foam comes in all kinds of qualities with lots of different features. The two most common types of foam used in a topper are memory foam and latex foam.

Best Mattress Toppers

Memory Foam Toppers

Memory foam toppers are good options for people that want the added hug and contour of memory foam. These toppers will conform more to your body, cradling you and making for a more supportive sleep experience. Memory foam toppers will also reduce the bounce and motion transfer you get from your current mattress.

Latex Foam Toppers

Latex is another popular option for mattress toppers. It offers some of the qualities of memory foam, but to a lesser extreme. That means you’ll get some body hug and contour, but not as much as you get with memory foam. This can help prevent the sinking feeling that some people get as their body eases into a layer of memory foam. Some people like this feeling, but others find it off-putting.

Moreover, you can use a latex foam topper to reduce the memory foam effects of a memory foam mattress. Latex produces sharper contours and less hug. Latex also offers more bounce than memory foam, so a latex topper can be one way to add some spice to your love life while extending the life of your current mattress.

Depth

The next thing to consider is how thick of a topper you want. This is an important thing to get right, as the thicker your topper, the less interaction you’ll get with your actual mattress. If you’re using a topper to extend the life of an old mattress, then a thicker topper will be a good idea. However, if you want a topper to enhance the way your mattress feels, then a thinner topper might be the best option.

Firmness

Firmness is also an important consideration when buying a topper. This is especially true for people that want to alter the feel of their bed. After all, if you have a mattress that’s too soft, getting a soft topper won’t help you much.

Firmness is also important because it can affect the sinkage qualities of the mattress. A firm topper can help increase the life of a mattress by reducing wear and tear. However, a firm mattress topper can also create awkward sensations as you rest on it, especially if you’ve got a very soft bed.

In the same way, a soft topper is a great way to add a more comfortable layer to a bed. This can help you make a cheap mattress feel like a luxury hotel. As a result, getting the firmness right can be the difference between a good night’s sleep and more tossing and turning at night.

Heat Regulation

Heat regulation is important. Studies show that people sleep better when they stay cool. Therefore, you should make sure any mattress topper you get will help move heat away from your body. Cheaper memory foam toppers can actually work to trap air. That increases the amount of heat that stays on your body and can make for an uncomfortable night’s sleep. Try to learn everything you can about the structure of the foam in a mattress topper. Things like gel-infusion or open-air cells are good signs that a mattress topper will help lower the amount of heat your bed holds on to.

Cover

The cover may not seem like an important aspect of a mattress topper, but that’s not the case. The quality of the cover directly affects how you interact with the topper. A scratchy cover or a cheap cover can lead to tears, which will make your topper less comfortable. Moreover, you want a cover that’s made from a machine-washable material to make keeping your bed nice and fresh as easy as possible.

Cost

Finally, you should consider the cost of a mattress topper. Toppers can range anywhere from $30 to $300, so there’s a wide range of budget options available. You want to make sure you spend enough on a topper to get the qualities you’re looking for, but you also want to make sure you’re not overspending on the topper, as you can almost afford a new mattress for the price of some of the higher end mattress toppers on the market today.

Best Latex Topper: Plushbeds

The Plushbed latex topper is the best latex topper around for the value it provides. One of the things we like best about this topper is that you can choose the firmness, cover, and thickness. That means you can customize it to create the exact sleep experience you’ve been looking for. Plushbed’s latex topper is made from 100% natural Talalay latex. It doesn’t include any clay fillers, chemical dyes, pesticides, bleach, or any other harmful chemicals. The Talaly process is famous for producing a consistent and high-quality latex, so you know you’ll be getting your money’s worth with the Plushbed Latex Topper.

Best Mattress Toppers

Best Value Topper: Puffy

The Puffy mattress topper is a great choice for people that want to keep away from harmful chemicals. The topper is OEKO-TEX certified using 100% certified materials. Additionally, the topper does a great job of helping move heat away from your body. It’s made from 40% bamboo and 60% polyester. That means you’ll stay cool and comfortable throughout the entire night.

Another reason to choose the puffy topper is that it comes with a lifetime warranty. That’s something you don’t even get with some of the best mattresses on the market today, much less mattress toppers. As a result, you can rest easy knowing that if anything goes wrong, you’ll have the support and backup you need to make it right.

Finally, we love the durable stretch pockets that Puffy includes with all of their toppers. These pockets make it easy to secure the topper to the mattress. As a result, the topper stays in place and allows you to get a comfortable night’s sleep without the topper shifting or moving around at night.

Best Mattress Toppers

Best Luxury Topper: Saatva

Saatva has three different options when it comes to mattress toppers: a graphite-infused foam, latex foam, or a high-density foam option. Each of these is made from the highest quality materials and will be sure to make your bed feel like the highest-quality hotel bed you’ve ever been on.

The graphite option is ideal for people that sleep hot and want a cooler night’s rest. Graphite works to move heat away from your body so it can dissipate, keeping you cool all night long. It also comes with a memory foam layer that provides extra contouring and support. Finally, there’s a high-density foam core which minimizes motion transfer, allowing you to rest easy no matter how much your partner tosses and turns.

The latex topper is made from natural sourced renewable latex. The foam itself is made from a combination of ventilated latex and organic cotton. As a result, it stays cool and breathable all night long. The latex used in the construction of this topper is extremely durable, so you can be confident that your topper will last for a long time, ensuring you get the value out of it that you put into it.

The final option for Saatva is their high-density memory foam topper. This topper is 1.5 inches thick, so it’s a great option for people that are looking for a bit of extra support without completely changing how their bed feels. The high-density foam does a good job of providing support when and where your body needs it. Saatva describes the firmness of this topper as “just right” meaning it’s good for almost every sleeper and every sleep style.

Best Mattress Toppers

Best Organic Topper: Naturepedic

Naturepedic’s 3” Wooly topper is the best certified organic topper on the market today. It’s a great option for people that are looking to add softness to their bed without changing the support they get from their mattress. Our favorite feature of this topper is the thick layers of organic wool batting that give you supportive full-body cushioning and pressure point relief.

Another thing to love about this topper is the fact that wool does a great job providing thermal regulation. Wool natural wicks moisture away, which helps cool you down at night. It also works to reduce sweating, so you’ll wake up feeling dry and comfortable.

The cover for this mattress is made from organic cotton sateen fiber. This finish adds a sense of luxury to the topper that you don’t really get from competitors. Moreover, it’s made without harmful chemicals and is GOTS and UL certified.

Naturepedic offers a 90-night trial for the topper, so you’ll have plenty of time to make sure it’s just what you’re looking for. The 90-night trial also comes with free shipping and free returns, so there’s no risk for trying it. If you decide you want to keep the Wooly topper, then you’ll enjoy a 10-year limited warranty, providing a great peace of mind as well as a restful night’s sleep.

Best Mattress Toppers

Best Gel Topper: Nest Alexander

Nest Alexander’s signature topper is one of the best options for people that want a cooler night’s sleep. The topper includes gel-infused memory foam. Gel-infusion helps create air channels in the foam to remove heat. The gel itself also acts to take heat away from your body to help you sleep cooler.

This topper is 2 inches thick, which is a great medium thickness, allowing you to alter the way your mattress feels without removing it entirely from the equation. Another thing we really like about this topper is the 4 straps which help secure the topper to the mattress. That means there’s no accidentally coming undone in the middle of the night and you can be sure the topper won’t be falling of the bed anytime soon. For more information do some research on Nest’s Energex Foam, which is an extremely high-quality memory foam used in all Nest Alexander Toppers.

Best Mattress Toppers

Which Mattress Topper is Right For You?

As you can see, there are a wide range of options when it comes to mattress toppers. Making sure you know what you’re looking for and how to get it is essential. That’s why you should use the information in this guide to pick out the perfect mattress topper for your needs. Whether you’re extending the life of a bed or just giving the feel of your mattress a little tweak to make it even more perfect, a mattress topper is a great way to ensure that you get the night’s sleep you deserve. Consider the options we’ve listed above to find the perfect mattress topper for your needs today!

What They Say

4.6
4.6 rating
4.6 out of 5 stars (based on 5 reviews)
Excellent60%
Very good40%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

Submit a Review